Dominik Mysterio: Betrayals, Alliances & WWE Mayhems

In the unpredictable world of WWE, few storylines in 2025 are commanding more attention than the tangled triangle between Dominik Mysterio, JD McDonagh, and Liv Morgan. What started as subtle backstage segments and social media winks has now snowballed into one of the most watched and speculated arcs in the current WWE landscape.

Dominik Mysterio, once just the wide-eyed son of legendary luchador Rey Mysterio, has completely shattered that label. Over the last two years, he’s transformed into a cocky, unapologetic heel — and in doing so, has become one of WWE’s most compelling characters. No longer walking in his father’s shadow, Dominik is now carving his controversial path, whether fans like it or not.

But it’s who’s walking that path with him that’s raising eyebrows.

On one side, we have JD McDonagh, the sinister technician and longtime associate of Finn Bálor. Once a quiet enforcer within the Judgment Day stable, McDonagh is now eyeing a larger role — and that may put him on a collision course with Dominik himself.

And then, there’s Liv Morgan — unpredictable, bold, and increasingly mysterious. Her recent appearances alongside Dominik, both in and out of the ring, have set off waves of speculation: Is she allying? Is she manipulating the group? Or is she setting the entire faction up for a brutal collapse?

This blog unpacks everything:

How Dominik rose from legacy kid to headline-grabbing villain.
JD McDonagh’s calculated climb through the ranks.
Liv Morgan’s wildcard status — and what her next move might be.

Fan theories, potential betrayals, romantic rumors, and major match setups.

We’ll break down the storylines, character development, backstage reports, and what it could all mean for the future of WWE’s most chaotic factional drama — a level of unpredictability that rivals even sports figures like Ilona Maher in her own rising spotlight.

Let’s start with Dominik — the center of the storm.

Who is Dominik Mysterio? From Legacy Son to Ruthless Heel

A Wrestling Heritage Unlike Any Other

Dominik Mysterio was born into wrestling royalty. As the son of Rey Mysterio, a globally beloved WWE Hall of Famer and one of the greatest cruiserweights in WWE history, Dominik’s destiny seemed written in the stars.

His earliest on-screen appearance came when he was just eight years old, caught in a high-stakes custody storyline between Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero — an angle that remains one of the most talked-about storylines in WWE history.

But while his surname opened doors, it also came with crushing pressure. Fans questioned whether Dominik could ever live up to his father’s legacy. For a long time, he existed in Rey’s shadow — respectful, loyal, and baby-faced. That version of Dominik is now gone.

The 2020 Debut and the Rise of “Prison Dom”

Dominik made his official in-ring WWE debut in 2020, facing Seth Rollins in a street fight at SummerSlam. Despite losing, he impressed many with his agility, in-ring poise, and storytelling instincts.

But real traction didn’t come until he turned heel in late 2022, joining Judgment Day, a dark and enigmatic faction led by Finn Bálor and Rhea Ripley. It was a character shift that fans didn’t see coming, and it completely transformed his WWE career.

He adopted a new persona: “Prison Dom”, a self-parodying, overly serious ex-convict gimmick that became instantly meme-worthy and strangely compelling.

“I had a hard time… you don’t know what it’s like in there!”
— Dominik Mysterio, after allegedly spending a few hours in a holding cell (kayfabe)

This comedic yet cocky version of Dominik clicked with fans and critics alike, as WWE leaned into the absurdity. And with the unwavering support of Rhea Ripley as his on-screen enforcer and love interest, he became one of WWE’s most hated — and watched — characters.

Dominik in 2025: Contender, Manipulator, or Pawn?

Now, in 2025, Dominik is no longer viewed as a rookie. He’s a staple on WWE RAW, frequently in high-profile matches, title scenes, and major PPVs.

His character has also matured:

He’s less comedic, more manipulative, and tactical.
He plays mind games, uses alliances to his advantage, and constantly dodges accountability.

He’s flirted with championship opportunities — including the North American Championship and potential mid-card runs.

But with rising tensions inside Judgment Day — especially with JD McDonagh’s emergence — fans are wondering:

Is Dominik still in control?
Or is he about to be outsmarted by someone darker and more dangerous?

That brings us to the next chapter of this story — JD McDonagh, the shadow lurking behind the throne.

Dominik Mysterio and JD McDonagh – Allies or Rivals in Waiting?

In WWE, trust is often the first thing that gets broken, especially when power, titles, and influence are on the line. That’s exactly what makes the current alliance between Dominik Mysterio and JD McDonagh so intriguing.

Are they working together toward a common goal?
Or are they merely waiting for the perfect moment to stab each other in the back?

Who is JD McDonagh?

Before aligning with Dominik and the Judgment Day, JD McDonagh was best known by his former ring name, Jordan Devlin, a standout in NXT UK and a former Cruiserweight Champion. Trained by Finn Bálor, JD’s wrestling IQ, twisted persona, and calculated aggression made him one of WWE’s most dangerous under-the-radar stars.

When he transitioned to the main roster, it was only natural that he gravitated toward Finn and the Judgment Day. But while others in the group wore their chaos on their sleeves, JD was always the quiet strategist, watching, calculating, and slowly inserting himself into the faction’s affairs.

Timeline of Their Alliance

Dominik and JD began sharing more screen time in late 2023. Initially, JD acted as a background enforcer, someone who backed up the faction but rarely got involved in politics.

By mid-2024, however, things shifted:

JD began saving Dominik in matches, not just on orders, but proactively.
Tag matches between the two became more frequent.

Shared promos hinted at growing mutual respect — or quiet competition.

In backstage segments, they often stood side by side. But the body language told a different story: cautious glances, lingering stares, interrupted sentences. WWE planted the seeds of doubt, and fans noticed.

Are They Teammates or Threats?

Their chemistry is undeniable — together, they offer a blend of brawler and technician, brute force and cold strategy. But this dynamic raises key questions:

Is JD using Dominik to gain more visibility?

Does Dominik see JD as a threat to his standing in Judgment Day?
Could this be a slow-burn betrayal arc leading to a future PPV showdown?

As of now, WWE is teasing tension, but not rushing the payoff — a classic slow build that creates long-term investment.

Power Struggle Within Judgment Day?

The biggest twist could be internal — within Judgment Day itself.

With Rhea Ripley frequently absent due to injuries or championship obligations, the leadership vacuum has left Dominik and JD circling each other. Both want control. Both want loyalty. And neither seems willing to play second fiddle.

“The only thing more dangerous than a traitor… is a friend who’s waiting for the right time to strike.”
– WWE commentary, hinting at JD’s motives

This internal tension could lead to:

A split faction (Judgment Day vs Judgment Day 2.0)
A shocking JD turn on Dominik before SummerSlam
A triple-threat leadership angle with Finn Bálor caught in the middle

What Fans Are Saying (Social Media & Speculation)

“JD is gonna destroy Dominik and take his spot in Judgment Day.” – Reddit
“What if JD and Liv are working together to tear it all down?” – X (formerly Twitter)
“This is going to be the Rollins vs Ambrose slow burn all over again.” – Discord fan server

The buzz is real, and WWE is leaning into it — dropping cryptic promos, cutting backstage interviews short, and teasing betrayal through body language and segment pacing.

As the power games intensify, a new player is entering the fray — Liv Morgan. Is she a wild card, a love interest, or a ticking time bomb?

Let’s explore that in the next section.

The Liv Morgan Connection – New Alliance or Swerve in Progress?

In the ever-shifting world of WWE storylines, few moves stir the pot like an unexpected alliance. Enter Liv Morgan — one of WWE’s most unpredictable and polarizing superstars — now positioned at the heart of a tangled narrative involving Dominik Mysterio and JD McDonagh.

While Liv has long stood out as a fan favorite for her resilience, edginess, and wild charisma, 2025 has seen her stepping into a darker, more calculated role — one that may go far beyond the ring.

Liv Morgan’s 2025 Reinvention

Once viewed as the underdog with heart, Liv Morgan is no longer the same performer fans rallied behind during her SmackDown Women’s Championship run in 2022.

Since returning from injury in early 2025, Liv has:

Dropped the overly bubbly persona.

Embraced mind games, aggressive promos, and surprise attacks.
Teased allegiances with morally gray or outright heel characters.

She’s no longer the overlooked star — she’s now the center of attention, whether in singles feuds or faction crossovers.

What’s Her Role in the Dominik–JD Storyline?

Over recent weeks, fans have picked up on subtle — and sometimes not-so-subtle — signs of Liv getting involved in Dominik’s business:

Shared backstage screen time.
Teasing eye contact and cryptic grins during live promos.
Interference in matches involving either Dominik or JD.

These moments are brief but deliberate. WWE isn’t just throwing Liv into this narrative randomly — they’re building her up as a potential chaos agent.

So the question becomes:

Is Liv Morgan helping Dominik… or setting him up for a fall?

Romantic Tease or Psychological Manipulation?

The WWE Universe is buzzing with speculation that Liv’s interaction with Dominik is more than professional.

Some fans suggest WWE is laying the groundwork for a romantic storyline — something that would create direct conflict with Rhea Ripley, Dominik’s long-standing on-screen partner.

Others believe Liv is manipulating Dominik to undermine Judgment Day from within — either for revenge or to build a faction of her own.

Either way, this layered storytelling is exactly what keeps fans glued to their screens.

“Liv is the kind of wildcard who doesn’t choose sides — she chooses chaos.”
– Fan comments on WWE’s YouTube livestream

Is Liv Aligning With the JD Instead?

Here’s where things get even murkier: what if Liv isn’t targeting Dominik at all?

What if she’s aligned with JD McDonagh — quietly working behind the scenes to dismantle Judgment Day and create a new, twisted power couple of her own?

Some breadcrumbs fueling this theory:

JD and Liv share similar dark, outsider personas.

Neither is afraid to break rules or blur moral lines.
Their combined cunning could easily outmaneuver Dominik.

Could This Lead to a New Faction?

WWE loves evolution — and this could be the start of one:

Liv + JD + a betrayed Dominik = Judgment Day 2.0?
Or Liv + JD against Dominik + a returning Rey Mysterio?

A faction shift here could ripple through both the men’s and women’s divisions, introducing new feuds, tag matches, and storyline intersections with superstars like:

Rhea Ripley (as a betrayed leader)

Finn Bálor (caught in faction politics)
Becky Lynch or Bianca Belair (as Liv’s future opponents)

Fan Speculation Is Exploding

“Liv is about to burn everything down. She’s not with anyone — she’s playing everyone.” – Reddit

Dominik is getting too comfortable. Liv’s going to be the one to wake him up, hard.” – TikTok comment
“JD and Liv running the new Judgment Day would be INSANE. Dark chaos vibes.” – Twitter/X

The intrigue surrounding Liv’s next move is sky-high — and WWE knows it.

FAQs — What Everyone Wants to Know

As Dominik Mysterio, JD McDonagh, and Liv Morgan continue to dominate WWE headlines and search trends, fans have been flooding Google, Reddit, and wrestling forums with questions. Below are clear, well-structured answers to the most common queries, built for both search visibility and reader engagement.

What happened between Dominik Mysterio and JD McDonagh?

Answer: Dominik and JD McDonagh are currently aligned within WWE’s Judgment Day faction, but tensions are rising. While they’ve been allies in tag matches and backstage segments, subtle power struggles and strategic missteps suggest that a future betrayal or internal war could be on the horizon. WWE is teasing a potential feud or faction split heading into the next big pay-per-view season.

Is Liv Morgan joining Judgment Day?

Answer: As of now, Liv Morgan has not officially joined Judgment Day, but all signs point toward a possible future involvement. Her increasingly dark persona, unexpected appearances during Dominik’s segments, and lack of current alliances suggest she may be aligning with or manipulating members of the group. WWE is keeping her role intentionally vague, fueling fan theories.

Are Dominik Mysterio and Liv Morgan dating?

Answer: There is no confirmed real-life relationship between Dominik Mysterio and Liv Morgan. Their recent on-screen chemistry and shared segments have sparked romance rumors, but WWE has not confirmed anything beyond storyline interactions. Dominik is still linked on-screen to Rhea Ripley, making any tease with Liv part of a potential feud or twist, not a confirmed romance.

What faction is JD McDonagh part of?

Answer: JD McDonagh is currently associated with Judgment Day, alongside Dominik Mysterio, Finn Bálor, Damian Priest, and Rhea Ripley. However, unlike core members, JD’s status has always been slightly ambiguous — he operates more like a dark lieutenant or backup brain, suggesting he might eventually challenge or reshape the faction from within.

Who is more powerful in WWE right now: JD McDonagh or Dominik?

Answer: In terms of match wins and weekly screen time, Dominik Mysterio still holds more influence. However, JD McDonagh’s strategic presence and ties to Finn Bálor make him a major threat. Power in WWE isn’t just about titles — it’s about momentum, alliances, and who delivers when it matters. Right now, both are strong — but only one may survive the next internal showdown.

Where is Rey Mysterio in all of this?

Answer: Rey Mysterio has been largely absent from the current storyline but remains a key emotional presence in Dominik’s arc. WWE could be saving his return for a high-impact moment — possibly to intervene if Dominik spirals or becomes a target. Fan theories suggest Rey may appear in a redemptive father-son story, or one final match against his son.

Is Judgment Day splitting up in 2025?

Answer: There’s no official confirmation, but storyline signs — rising tension between Dominik and JD, Liv’s unclear intentions, and Rhea Ripley’s limited presence — all point to internal cracks. Whether the group evolves or explodes will likely unfold at a major event like SummerSlam or Survivor Series.

This FAQ section not only addresses fan curiosity but also reinforces semantic connections between key terms like:

Dominik Mysterio
Liv Morgan

Judgment Day
JD McDonagh
WWE betrayal storylines

WWE factions 2025

What Happens Next? Predictions, Betrayals & Big Matches Ahead

The triangle between Dominik Mysterio, JD McDonagh, and Liv Morgan isn’t just a segment-by-segment feud — it’s being built as a long-game arc, one that WWE could stretch across pay-per-views, factions, and possibly a full brand shift.

Let’s break down what might happen next, based on current momentum and fan speculation.

1. Betrayal Is Inevitable — But Who Strikes First?

With Dominik gaining screen time and ego, and JD operating as a quiet strategist, betrayal feels inevitable. The real question is who initiates it:

JD McDonagh could finally turn on Dominik in a power grab.
Dominik could preemptively strike if he senses JD becoming a threat.
Or Liv Morgan could outplay them both, exposing personal motives behind her involvement.

Most likely betrayal: JD blindsiding Dominik to “save” Judgment Day from weakness.

2. Liv Morgan’s Real Plan Unfolds

Three potential paths for Liv Morgan’s character arc:

Manipulator: She’s stringing both men along, waiting for the perfect moment to burn the group from within.
Romantic Catalyst: WWE leans into a love triangle or emotional feud, creating tension between Liv, Rhea, and Dominik.
Faction Founder: Liv and JD secretly form a new, dark duo, creating Judgment Day 2.0 or a fresh heel faction.

Each route offers layered storytelling and opens new feuds for Liv, whether against Rhea Ripley, Becky Lynch, or even Charlotte Flair.

3. Potential Matches at Upcoming WWE PPVs

Here’s how these storylines could evolve into high-stakes matches:

Event	Match Idea	Stipulation/Storyline
Backlash	JD McDonagh vs Dominik Mysterio	Internal collapse — the winner stays in Judgment Day
Money in the Bank	Liv Morgan vs Rhea Ripley (if cleared)	Jealousy, power struggle, or revenge
SummerSlam	Mixed Tag: Liv & Dominik vs JD & Rhea	Faction warfare + emotional stakes
Survivor Series	Team JD vs Team Dominik (5v5 Elimination)	Full-blown split — faction vs faction

This storyline is perfect for long-form storytelling — a rarity in WWE when done right.

4. What Fans Want to See

From Reddit threads to TikTok comments, fan theories are exploding:

“JD is going to be the new leader. Dom is a pawn.”
“Liv is turning on both. She’s playing chess while they play checkers.”
“I need Rey to return and drag his son out of this madness.”

WWE is feeding this buzz by:

Using subtle cues (camera angles, body language, lingering promos).
Dropping cryptic quotes in commentary.
Booking matches that don’t resolve — they escalate.

It’s a masterclass in slow-burn faction drama, a storytelling style that hasn’t been this well-executed since The Shield or Evolution.

Final Outcome: A Reboot or a Reset?

No matter who turns on whom, one thing is clear:

The Judgment Day won’t look the same by the end of 2025.

Whether Liv becomes its leader, JD tears it apart, or Dominik redeems (or destroys) it from the inside — this story has legs, heart, and heat.

And the best part?
It’s still unfolding.

References & External Sources

To ensure credibility and accuracy, this article references key wrestling journalism sources, social media insights, and WWE’s official updates:

Source	Purpose
WWE.com	Official storyline recaps, superstar profiles
Sportskeeda Wrestling	Latest updates, quotes, and behind-the-scenes reports
Fightful Select	Insider scoops on booking directions and contracts
Reddit – r/SquaredCircle	Fan theories, live reactions, speculation
[Twitter/X: #DominikMysterio, #LivMorgan, #JD]	Trending discussions and community sentiment
YouTube – WWE Official	Live promos, match segments, and commentary teasers

Conclusion:

The alliance or collision course between Dominik Mysterio, JD McDonagh, and Liv Morgan is shaping up to be one of the most layered and unpredictable arcs WWE has seen in recent years.

Dominik, once dismissed as Rey’s quiet son, now stands at the center of chaos. JD McDonagh, always watching and calculating, is slowly shifting the balance of power. And Liv Morgan? She may be the most dangerous of all — not because of brute force, but because no one knows whose side she’s on.

This story blends classic wrestling themes — betrayal, ambition, manipulation — with modern WWE storytelling: long-form arcs, social media teases, and factional warfare.

Whether you’re here for the matches, the drama, or the mind games, one thing is certain:

This story is far from over, and the next move could change everything.

Stay tuned.
Because in WWE, nothing is ever what it seems — especially when three of the most untrustworthy names in the business are playing the game.

WWE 2025: Dominik Mysterio, JD McDonagh & Liv Morgan — The Most Twisted Alliance Yet?